DIY Flavored Coffee Creamer

DIY Flavored Coffee Creamer

Product Code: R0411

Making your own flavored coffee creamer is easy with Super Strength flavors! Mix and match your favorite flavors to create a sweet and smooth creamer that will make the perfect addition to your coffee. A few flavors we love in this creamer recipe are amaretto, caramel, and chocolate hazelnut.

Use in hot or iced coffee. Creamer will last up to two weeks in the refrigerator. 

Print Recipe PDF


2 cups milk (1% or 2%)
1 can (14 oz.) sweetened condensed milk
1 dram (1 tsp.) LorAnn Super Strength flavor of choice (or to taste)
Empty jar with lid


1. Add milk, sweetened condensed milk, and Super Strength flavor into an empty jar.
2. Place lid on the jar and begin to shake vigorously.
3. Once the creamer is mixed fully, add to hot or iced coffee and enjoy!
(Based on 3 vote(s))
3 review(s) | Add your review!
Average Rating:
(Based on 3 vote(s))
We would love a review from you for this item!
Becca From United States
Weird taste
September 4, 2022
Made homemade coffee creamer and used less than half the recommended amount of cinnamon oil. Horrible flavor and aftertaste. Threw out that batch. Will try again with drops at a time to see.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you? (1) (0)
Barry From United States
Not terrible, but weird aftertaste.
March 5, 2022
Not terrible, but weird aftertaste. Likely because of the condensed milk. Maybe if you use half and half or light cream, it would be better. Nothing beats the Dunkin Donuts extra extra creamer. Looking to duplicate that and this wasn't even close.
1 of 2 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you? (1) (1)
TKathlete From Georgia
Almond Coffee Juice
October 23, 2021
I usually get this specialized coffee creamer when I visit a coffee shop in San Antonio, (their secret recipe). Well, I found the holy grail in making this fantastic Coffee Creamer. Thank you. I used the caramel flavoring. YUM. Although I must admit, it was a tad too sweet.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you? (1) (0)
You may also be interested in
Caramel Flavor 1 dram
  • $1.60
Amaretto Flavor 1 dram
  • $1.60
Chocolate Hazelnut Flavor 1 dram
  • $1.60